BP share price falls as buybacks are suspended — but is the market focusing on the wrong story?
For years, BP (LSE: BP.) prioritised share buybacks at the expense of balance sheet strength, while its share price consistently underperformed its peers. With buybacks now paused and strategy refocused, could this mark the start of a far leaner business?
Full-year results
The strategic reset is visible in the numbers. The oil majorâs fourth-quarter performance was broadly in line with expectations, but it also underlined why balance sheet repair has taken priority over continued share buybacks.
Underlying replacement cost profit fell to $1.5bn for the quarter, down from $2.2bn previously, reflecting lower upstream realisations, production mix effects and refinery disruption.
Reported results swung to a $3.4bn loss, largely due to around $4bn of non-cash impairments. A significant portion came from its low-carbon assets, including Archaea, its biogas operations, and offshore wind projects.
Cash flow remained strong. Operating cash flow of $7.6bn comfortably covered the dividend, which was held at 8.32 cents per share. Similarly, net debt reduced to $22.2bn, following a number of divestments throughout the year.
If the company can generate this level of cash in a weak oil price environment, what happens if oil demand proves far more durable than the market expects?
Peak oil demand
For more than a decade, investors were told oil demand would peak by 2030. That assumption underpinned valuation models and political rhetoric â and itâs now breaking down.
In its World Energy Outlook 2025, the International Energy Agency quietly abandoned the idea of an imminent peak. Its latest projections show oil and gas demand rising well into the 2050s. Thatâs not a tweak â it blows a hole in one of the most widely held assumptions in energy markets.
The reason is simple: the world needs energy, delivered instantly and at scale. Homes need heat, economies need growth, and AI-driven data centres are driving surging power demand that renewables alone cannot meet.
Nuclear can scale long term, but deployment is too slow; over the next decade, natural gas is the only viable bridge.
Solar, wind and hydrogen are growing, but they remain additive, not substitutes. Fossil fuels still dominate the global energy mix.
This matters for BP. As the peak-oil narrative fades, itâs refocusing on upstream. Six new projects in 2025 added 150,000 barrels per day, and the huge Bumerangue discovery in Brazil ensures a robust pipeline for years to come.
Risks
The main risks are political and financial. With oil and gas strategically essential, governments may push for higher taxes, royalties, or regulatory burdens, especially in regions where the industry is heavily scrutinised.
Capital allocation is another key challenge. Buybacks may have been suspended, but hitting the net debt target of $14bn-$18bn cannot rely solely on divestments like Castrol. The company may need to shrink its asset base significantly before it can credibly signal long-term growth again.
Whatâs the verdict?
BP doesnât have a cash flow problem, but the balance sheet still carries assets written down from past missteps. Repair will weigh on investors in the short term.
Personally, I continue to add to my position gradually, reflecting my view that hydrocarbons remain central to global energy and that the companyâs strategy reset positions it for a leaner, more resilient future.
The post BP share price falls as buybacks are suspended â but is the market focusing on the wrong story? appeared first on The Motley Fool UK.
Should you invest £1,000 in BP p.l.c. right now?
When investing expert Mark Rogers has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for nearly a decade has provided thousands of paying members with top stock recommendations from the UK and US markets.
And right now, Mark thinks there are 6 standout stocks that investors should consider buying. Want to see if BP p.l.c. made the list?
More reading
- See what £10,000 invested in resurgent BP shares 1 month ago is worth nowâ¦
- How much would an ISA need to be worth for someone to aim for a £10,000 annual passive income?
- £100,000 in savings? Here’s how to target a £10,000 passive income!
- Prediction: in 12 months the surging BP share price and dividend could turn £10,000 intoâ¦
- The BP share price: a once-in-a-decade chance to get richer?
Andrew Mackie has positions in Bp P.l.c. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.
